Koinly vs. Cointracking: A Comprehensive Guide to Cryptocurrency Tax Software – Usage, Pricing, and Review

The burgeoning cryptocurrency market has brought with it an increasing complexity in tax compliance for traders and investors. In the United States, the IRS (Internal Revenue Service) explicitly categorizes virtual currency as ‘property,’ meaning that capital gains from sales or exchanges, ordinary income from activities like mining and staking, and even intricate transactions within DeFi (Decentralized Finance) and NFTs (Non-Fungible Tokens) are subject to detailed reporting. Manually calculating these tax liabilities can be an arduous and error-prone task, making specialized tax calculation software an indispensable tool.

This article provides an in-depth, comprehensive review and comparison of two of the most popular and feature-rich cryptocurrency tax software solutions: Koinly and Cointracking. We will delve into their functionalities, usage, pricing structures, and critically evaluate their pros and cons. By the end of this guide, you will possess a complete understanding necessary to select the software that best suits your needs and confidently navigate your crypto tax obligations.

Fundamentals of Cryptocurrency Taxation

Cryptocurrency’s Tax Classification

The IRS treats cryptocurrency as ‘property,’ similar to stocks or real estate. This implies that any profit (capital gain) realized from selling or exchanging crypto assets is subject to taxation. Furthermore, income derived from activities such as mining rewards, staking rewards, airdrops, or launchpad allocations is considered ‘ordinary income’ at its fair market value at the time of receipt. This fair market value then establishes the cost basis for these assets if they are subsequently sold.

Key Taxable Events

Selling Cryptocurrency: Exchanging crypto for fiat currency.
Trading Cryptocurrency: Swapping one cryptocurrency for another (e.g., BTC for ETH) is considered two separate taxable events: a sale of the first crypto and a purchase of the second.
Purchasing Goods/Services with Crypto: Using cryptocurrency to buy products or services.
Mining Rewards: Cryptocurrencies earned through mining.
Staking Rewards: Cryptocurrencies received from staking.
Airdrops & Hard Forks: Newly distributed cryptocurrencies.
DeFi Activities: Income from providing liquidity, yield farming, lending, etc.
NFT Sales/Exchanges: Profits from selling or exchanging NFTs are subject to capital gains tax.

Cost Basis Calculation Methods

Capital gains (or losses) are calculated as: “Sales Price – Cost Basis (Acquisition Cost) – Transaction Fees.” When selling a portion of a cryptocurrency that was acquired at different times and prices, determining which acquisition cost applies is crucial. Common methods include:

FIFO (First-In, First-Out): Assumes the first acquired coins are sold first. This is the most commonly adopted method.
LIFO (Last-In, First-Out): Assumes the most recently acquired coins are sold first.
HIFO (Highest-In, First-Out): Assumes coins with the highest cost basis are sold first, potentially minimizing tax liability.
Specific Identification: Allows you to specifically identify which lot of cryptocurrency is being sold. This offers the greatest tax efficiency but requires meticulous record-keeping.

Applying these calculation methods consistently across all transactions manually is exceedingly difficult. Tax software automates this process, ensuring accurate capital gain/loss calculations.

In-Depth Analysis: Koinly vs. Cointracking

Koinly: The Intuitive and User-Friendly Choice

Koinly Overview and Features

Koinly is renowned for its intuitive interface and ease of use, making it a highly favored cryptocurrency tax software. It is particularly well-suited for beginners in crypto tax and users who do not engage in overly complex DeFi transactions. Established in 2018, Koinly serves millions of users worldwide.

Key Features

Extensive Exchange & Wallet Integrations: Supports over 350 exchanges (e.g., Binance, Coinbase, Kraken) and wallets (e.g., MetaMask, Ledger, Trezor). Transaction history can be easily imported via API connections or CSV file uploads. Koinly also boasts strong integration with DeFi protocols (e.g., Uniswap, Aave) and NFT marketplaces (e.g., OpenSea).
Automatic Transaction Classification: Automatically categorizes imported transactions into tax-relevant types such as sales, purchases, swaps, transfers, and rewards. Users can easily manually correct any misclassifications.
Multiple Cost Basis Methods: Supports various calculation methods, including FIFO, LIFO, HIFO, and Average Costing, allowing users to select the most advantageous method for their situation and simulate tax outcomes.
Tax Report Generation: Generates essential reports for US tax filing, such as IRS Form 8949 (Sales and Other Dispositions of Capital Assets), Schedule D (Capital Gains and Losses), and Ordinary Income Reports. It also supports reports for other countries (e.g., Canada, UK, Australia).
Portfolio Tracking: Beyond tax calculations, Koinly provides real-time tracking of portfolio value, profit/loss, and historical performance.

Koinly User Experience

Koinly’s primary appeal lies in its superior User Interface (UI) and User Experience (UX). The dashboard is clear and easy to understand, and the entire process from transaction import to report generation is remarkably smooth. Its ability to identify and prompt users to fix unresolved transactions (e.g., unknown transfer destinations, missing cost basis) is particularly helpful for preventing common errors among new users.

Koinly Pricing Structure

Koinly offers different pricing plans based on transaction volume. While the free plan allows importing up to 10,000 transactions, generating tax reports requires a paid subscription.

Newbie (Free): Sync and manage up to 10,000 transactions. Limited to portfolio tracking; no tax report generation.
HODLER ($49/year): Up to 100 transactions. Enables generation of all main tax reports.
TRADER ($99/year): Up to 1,000 transactions. Includes HODLER features plus more customization options.
PRO ($179/year): Up to 10,000 transactions. Includes TRADER features plus priority support.
UNLIMITED ($279/year): Unlimited transactions. Includes PRO features plus advanced DeFi and NFT support.

*Prices are approximate for annual subscriptions and subject to change. Please check the official website for the latest information.

Cointracking: The Powerful and Detailed Choice for Professionals

Cointracking Overview and Features

Cointracking is a pioneer in cryptocurrency tax software, having been in service since 2013. Its long history translates into exceptionally broad support for exchanges and wallets, offering highly detailed reporting and advanced customization. It is particularly well-suited for professional traders with high transaction volumes and tax accountants requiring in-depth analysis.

Key Features

Unmatched Integration Count: Supports over 110 exchanges and wallets via API or CSV. Its custom CSV import feature is exceptionally powerful, allowing for manual import of virtually any transaction data. This flexibility is crucial for handling older exchanges or obscure DeFi protocols.
Advanced Reporting Capabilities: Beyond standard tax reports (IRS Form 8949, Schedule D), Cointracking generates over 50 types of detailed reports, including real-time profit/loss, realized/unrealized gains, income reports, fee reports, long-term/short-term capital gains, and audit reports. These reports are invaluable not only for tax filing but also for analyzing trading strategies.
Diverse Cost Basis Calculation Methods: Supports a wide array of methods including FIFO, LIFO, HIFO, Average Costing, and Specific Identification. Users can even apply different methods to specific transactions.
Accounting Features: Offers comprehensive features for managing crypto portfolios from an accounting perspective, such as automatic recognition of transaction fees and calculation of loss carryforwards.
Accountant Collaboration: Cointracking provides robust features for tax professionals, facilitating easy sharing of client data and collaborative work.

Cointracking User Experience

Due to its extensive feature set, Cointracking has a steeper learning curve compared to Koinly. While its UI might appear somewhat dated, once mastered, its customization and detailed data analysis capabilities are unparalleled. The flexibility to manually adjust numerous transactions and add detailed notes to specific entries is particularly strong.

Cointracking Pricing Structure

Cointracking also offers various pricing plans based on transaction volume, with options for annual and lifetime licenses.

Free: Up to 200 transactions. Provides basic portfolio tracking and limited reporting.
Pro ($199/year or $299/lifetime): Up to 3,500 transactions. Access to all reporting features.
Expert ($279/year or $499/lifetime): Up to 35,000 transactions. Includes Pro features plus more API connections and faster data processing.
Unlimited ($799/year or $2,499/lifetime): Unlimited transactions. Includes Expert features plus unlimited API connections, priority support, and accountant features.

*Prices are approximate for annual or lifetime licenses and subject to change. Please check the official website for the latest information.

Practical Case Studies and Calculation Examples

Let’s explore how Koinly and Cointracking handle tax calculations through specific scenarios. While their basic calculation logic is similar, differences emerge in terms of configuration flexibility and report detail.

Case Study 1: Simple Buy/Sell and Capital Gains

Scenario:

January 1, 2023: Purchased 1 BTC for $20,000 on Coinbase.
June 1, 2023: Sold 0.5 BTC for $30,000 on Coinbase.

Koinly/Cointracking Processing:

Import transaction history via Coinbase API integration or CSV file.
The software automatically identifies the ‘Buy’ and ‘Sell’ transactions.
Based on the default calculation method (e.g., FIFO), the cost basis for the 0.5 BTC sold is identified. In this case, half of the BTC purchased on Jan 1st applies, making the cost basis $10,000 ($20,000 * 0.5).
The capital gain is calculated as: “Sales Price ($15,000) – Cost Basis ($10,000) = $5,000.”
This gain will be reflected on IRS Form 8949 and Schedule D as a short-term capital gain (since the holding period is less than one year).

Case Study 2: Staking Rewards and Ordinary Income

Scenario:

March 1, 2023: Received 0.1 ETH as a staking reward on Kraken (market value at receipt: $1,800/ETH, total $180).
September 1, 2023: Sold the 0.1 ETH for $2,000/ETH (total $200).

Koinly/Cointracking Processing:

Import transaction history via Kraken API integration or CSV file.
The software automatically classifies the 0.1 ETH received on March 1st as a ‘Staking Reward.’
The market value at receipt ($180) is recorded as ‘Ordinary Income’ and reflected in Koinly/Cointracking’s income reports. This $180 also becomes the cost basis for this specific 0.1 ETH.
Upon the sale on September 1st, the software applies the cost basis of $180 and calculates the capital gain as: “Sales Price ($200) – Cost Basis ($180) = $20.”
Both the income report and capital gains report will accurately reflect these tax events.

Case Study 3: DeFi Swaps and Liquidity Provision

Scenario:

April 1, 2023: Swapped 1 ETH for 2,000 USDC on Uniswap V3 via MetaMask (ETH purchase price: $1,500).
May 1, 2023: Added 1,000 USDC and 0.5 ETH to a Uniswap V3 liquidity pool.
July 1, 2023: Withdrew from the liquidity pool, receiving 1,100 USDC and 0.45 ETH.

Koinly/Cointracking Processing:

Connect the MetaMask wallet address or import via CSV. For complex DeFi transactions, API integration alone may be insufficient, and manual adjustments or CSV imports are often recommended.
April 1st Swap: The software records this as a sale of 1 ETH (gain of $500 = $2,000 – $1,500) and a purchase of 2,000 USDC. This is a capital gains event.
May 1st Liquidity Provision: Adding assets to a liquidity pool is generally not considered a taxable event itself, but the software tracks it as a transfer and maintains the cost basis of each token. Koinly categorizes this as “Add to Pool,” while Cointracking might use “Deposit.”
July 1st Liquidity Withdrawal: Withdrawing from a pool can be a taxable event if the received tokens differ in quantity from the initial deposit (e.g., due to impermanent loss or gain). In this scenario, since only 0.45 ETH was received for an initial 0.5 ETH deposit, a loss of 0.05 ETH (or offset by an increase in USDC) occurs. The software calculates capital gains/losses based on the market value of the tokens at the time of withdrawal. Koinly excels in automatic detection of DeFi transactions, while Cointracking offers more detailed manual adjustment options.
Gas fees (network fees) are also processed based on the software’s default settings or user choices, either by adding them to the cost basis of the transaction or treating them as separate expenses.

DeFi and NFT transactions are inherently complex, and software may not always achieve 100% accurate automatic classification. While Koinly generally offers higher accuracy in automatic classification, Cointracking provides more comprehensive manual correction options. It is critically important to review all generated reports thoroughly and make any necessary manual adjustments before final tax submission.

Pros and Cons of Koinly and Cointracking

Koinly Pros

Outstanding Ease of Use: Its intuitive and clean UI/UX makes it accessible even for beginners.
Strong DeFi and NFT Support: Seamless integration with many DeFi protocols and NFT marketplaces, often providing relatively accurate automatic classification for complex transactions.
Reasonable Pricing: Generally more cost-effective, especially for users with lower to moderate transaction volumes.
Excellent Visualization: Portfolio performance and profit/loss are clearly displayed with easy-to-understand graphs.

Koinly Cons

Transaction Volume Limits: Even the PRO plan has a 10,000 transaction limit, requiring very active traders to opt for the more expensive UNLIMITED plan.
Limited Customization: Compared to Cointracking, report customization and advanced accounting features are more limited.
Audit Features: Detailed historical tracking for tax professional audits is not as robust as Cointracking.

Cointracking Pros

Unparalleled Feature Richness: Offers over 50 types of reports, diverse cost basis methods, and advanced accounting features, catering to professional needs.
Extensive Integrations and Flexibility: Supports an enormous number of platforms, from older exchanges to the latest DeFi protocols, with a powerful custom CSV import function.
Detailed Data Analysis: Provides comprehensive data analysis from all angles, including portfolio performance, tax implications, and transaction fee breakdowns.
Accountant-Specific Features: Well-equipped for tax professionals to manage and audit client data.
Lifetime License Option: A lifetime license can be a cost-effective choice for long-term users.

Cointracking Cons

Steep Learning Curve: The abundance of features can be overwhelming for beginners. The UI also feels somewhat older and less intuitive compared to Koinly.
Higher Pricing: The Unlimited plan, in particular, can be quite expensive, potentially being overkill for small to medium-scale traders.
DeFi/NFT Automatic Classification: May not always be as accurate in automatic classification as Koinly, often requiring more manual adjustments.

Common Pitfalls and Important Considerations

Many cryptocurrency users fall into common traps when calculating their taxes. Paying attention to the following points can ensure a smooth and accurate filing process.

1. Incomplete Transaction History Import

The most common mistake is failing to import all transaction history. Many transactions are easily overlooked, such as old exchange accounts, small swaps on DEXs, or received airdrops. It is crucial to utilize both API integrations and CSV exports to comprehensively import data from all wallets and exchanges. Specifically, for transfers between wallets, ensure that both the sending and receiving ends have matching records.

2. Misclassification of Transactions

While software automates classification, it is not infallible. DeFi transactions (e.g., liquidity provision, yield farming, lending) and NFT transactions are particularly challenging for automatic categorization. For instance, the software might mistakenly classify a transfer between your own wallets as a sale or treat a gift as a regular transaction. Always manually review the generated reports and correct transaction types as needed.

3. Handling of Gas Fees (Network Fees)

Gas fees incurred on blockchains like Ethereum have complex tax implications. Generally, gas fees paid to complete a transaction can either be included in the cost basis of that transaction or deducted as an expense. However, some software might not automatically classify them correctly. Verify that gas fees for your transactions are processed appropriately.

4. Misunderstanding the Wash Sale Rule

In the US, the wash sale rule (which disallows a tax deduction for losses realized from selling a security if you buy a substantially identical security within 30 days before or after the sale) currently does not directly apply to cryptocurrencies. However, tax laws can change, and aggressive tax-loss harvesting followed by immediate repurchase might still carry some risk of being challenged by tax authorities. Always stay informed about the latest tax regulations and exercise caution when optimizing for tax purposes.

5. Neglecting Final Report Review

Cryptocurrency tax software is a powerful tool, but the ultimate responsibility lies with the taxpayer. Do not submit the generated reports without thorough scrutiny. Always verify the accuracy of the content against your own transaction history. It is particularly essential to review detailed records for transactions resulting in significant gains or losses.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q1: Is cryptocurrency tax software truly necessary?

A1: Yes, it is indispensable for most cryptocurrency users. While manual calculation might be feasible for a few simple buy/sell transactions, it becomes nearly impossible to accurately calculate taxes if you use multiple exchanges or wallets, engage in swaps, staking, DeFi, or NFT transactions. Software saves time, prevents calculation errors, and generates accurate reports that can withstand IRS scrutiny.

Q2: Which software is better for beginners, Koinly or Cointracking?

A2: For beginners in cryptocurrency tax calculation, Koinly is highly recommended. Its intuitive and clean user interface simplifies the complex tax process. The automatic transaction classification feature is excellent, allowing for a smooth journey from initial setup to report generation. Cointracking, while feature-rich, has a steeper learning curve, and beginners might find it challenging to master quickly.

Q3: Do these software tools support DeFi and NFT transactions?

A3: Yes, both Koinly and Cointracking support DeFi and NFT transactions, though with varying degrees of accuracy and automatic classification. Koinly actively enhances its API integrations with DeFi protocols and NFT marketplaces, often providing higher accuracy in automatic classification. Cointracking also supports them, but you might find yourself needing more detailed manual adjustments or custom CSV imports. For complex DeFi/NFT transactions, manual review and adjustment of the final reports are essential for both software.

Q4: What if my exchange is not supported by Koinly or Cointracking?

A4: Most major exchanges support API integration or CSV export. If your exchange is not directly supported by either software, you can typically create and import a CSV file manually. Both Koinly and Cointracking offer generic CSV import functions, allowing you to format your data to fit their requirements. Cointracking, in particular, offers greater flexibility for custom CSV imports. CSV import is also a valid alternative if API integration proves unstable.

Q5: Can I file my taxes using a free plan?

A5: No, neither Koinly nor Cointracking’s free plans allow you to generate official reports required for tax filing (such as IRS Form 8949). Free plans are designed for users to test the software’s features and interface, and while they can be used for basic portfolio tracking with a small number of transactions, an upgrade to a paid plan is necessary for tax reporting. You will need to choose an appropriate paid plan based on your transaction volume for either software.

Conclusion

Cryptocurrency tax filing, with its inherent complexities, can be a daunting task for many investors. However, leveraging specialized tax calculation software like Koinly and Cointracking can significantly streamline this process and enhance accuracy.

Koinly, with its superior user-friendly interface and intuitive operation, is an optimal choice for beginners in crypto tax and users with moderate transaction volumes. It excels in automatic classification of DeFi and NFT transactions and provides visually clear reports.
Cointracking, distinguished by its extensive feature set, broad integrations, and detailed customization options, is better suited for professional traders, users with high transaction volumes, or tax professionals. While it has a steeper learning curve, once mastered, it becomes a powerful tool capable of addressing virtually all tax-related needs.

The choice between these two software solutions depends on your transaction volume, the complexity of your trading activities, and your personal priorities regarding ease of use versus advanced functionality. We recommend starting with a free plan to test them out and determine which best fits your specific needs. The most critical aspect remains to accurately record all transactions, apply the correct cost basis calculation methods, and thoroughly review the generated reports before final submission. For complex tax situations or if you have any doubts, always consult with a professional tax accountant.

We hope this article serves as a valuable resource in selecting and utilizing Koinly or Cointracking, helping you navigate your cryptocurrency tax filing process more smoothly and accurately.

#Cryptocurrency Tax #Koinly #Cointracking #Tax Software #Crypto Accounting #IRS Guidance #Capital Gains #Tax Compliance #DeFi Tax #NFT Tax